Cognitive Biases · Belief

Backfire effect

Also called: Belief backfire

The idea that correcting someone's mistaken belief can make them hold it more strongly. Large studies find this is rare, and most people move toward the correction.

Evidence grade: Contested. How we grade evidence

A caution. Large replications find corrections usually work; true backfire is rare.

For example

A program lead presents audit results showing a program missed its targets. At the next board meeting, one member says the results only prove the program is needed even more.

DECIDE BETTER® · Rule 2Audit the good news tooIf the numbers agree with you, audit them as aggressively as the numbers that do not. We are just not wired to be contrarian to our own beliefs.

Spot it in your week

Three quick questions. Your answers stay on this page.

  1. When you shared a correction recently, did the person end up holding their original view even more firmly?
  2. In a recent meeting, did a correction seem to make someone dig in rather than reconsider?
  3. Did you read a comment thread this week where facts against a view were met with a stronger defense of it?

Your DecisionDNA™ can tell you which biases you're most exposed to.

Find your DecisionDNA™

Sources

Watch the explainer video⁠ (opens in a new tab)

Related entries

Get the countermeasure

Get the countermeasure and the decisions where this bites, free in the Volley app.

See the Volley app