Best Practices · Learning
Devil's Advocate
Also called: Dialectical inquiry (related)
One person deliberately argues against the prevailing view to test it.
Evidence grade: Mixed. How we grade evidenceFeatured
For example
In a hiring decision, one panelist argues the case for the runner-up candidate.
A caution
Assigned dissent helps less than genuine dissent; rotate it and give it real authority.
Spot it in your week
Three quick questions. Your answers stay on this page.
Your DecisionDNA™ can tell you which biases you're most exposed to.
Find your DecisionDNA™Featured sample
What helps
Rotate the role so dissent is expected, not personal.
Featured entries show a sample of what the Volley app gives you for every entry.
Sources
- Schwenk (1990). Effects of devil's advocacy and dialectical inquiry on decision making: A meta-analysis. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. (opens in a new tab)
- Nemeth et al. (2001). Devil's advocate versus authentic dissent: stimulating quantity and quality. European Journal of Social Psychology. (opens in a new tab)
Related entries
- Best PracticesRed TeamingAssigning people to attack a plan the way a skeptic or adversary would.
- Cognitive BiasesGroupthinkA group's desire for harmony overrides a realistic look at the alternatives.
- Cognitive BiasesConfirmation biasSeeking out and favoring information that confirms what you already believe.
Bias of the week
One decision trap a week, in plain English. Unsubscribe any time.
We send one confirmation email first. What we keep.
Get the full playbook
Get the countermeasure and the decisions where this bites, free in the Volley app.
