Best Practices · Learning

Devil's Advocate

Also called: Dialectical inquiry (related)

One person deliberately argues against the prevailing view to test it.

Evidence grade: Mixed. How we grade evidenceFeatured

For example

In a hiring decision, one panelist argues the case for the runner-up candidate.

DECIDE BETTER® · Rule 2Audit the good news tooIf the numbers agree with you, audit them as aggressively as the numbers that do not. We are just not wired to be contrarian to our own beliefs.

A caution

Assigned dissent helps less than genuine dissent; rotate it and give it real authority.

Spot it in your week

Three quick questions. Your answers stay on this page.

  1. Did you take a side in a recent decision mainly to test the prevailing view, even if you agreed with it?
  2. In a recent meeting, did someone argue for the runner-up option on purpose?
  3. Did you read a decision memo this week that included a deliberate case against the chosen option?

Your DecisionDNA™ can tell you which biases you're most exposed to.

Find your DecisionDNA™

Featured sample

What helps

Rotate the role so dissent is expected, not personal.

Featured entries show a sample of what the Volley app gives you for every entry.

Sources

Watch the explainer video⁠ (opens in a new tab)

Related entries

Get the full playbook

Get the countermeasure and the decisions where this bites, free in the Volley app.

See the Volley app