Best Practices · Learning

Mediating assessments protocol

Also called: Structured decision protocol

Defining the key criteria up front, scoring each one separately on its own evidence, and holding off on an overall judgment until all the scores are in.

Evidence grade: Practitioner. How we grade evidence

For example

A selection committee for a new executive director talks about each candidate overall and settles on whoever left the best impression. Criteria such as finance experience and community ties are never scored on their own.

DECIDE BETTER® · Rule 4Decide on the ingredientsName the criteria and weigh them before you argue about the winner. Not everything matters equally; saying so is just not wanting to do the work.

A caution

Built on strong evidence for structured interviews. The protocol itself has few direct tests.

Spot it in your week

Three quick questions. Your answers stay on this page.

  1. Did you form an overall impression of an option this week before looking at its parts?
  2. In a meeting this week, did a group pick the option that felt right without scoring any criteria?
  3. Did you read a recommendation this week that gave a verdict without separate ratings behind it?

Your DecisionDNA™ can tell you which biases you're most exposed to.

Find your DecisionDNA™

Sources

Related entries

Get the countermeasure

Get the countermeasure and the decisions where this bites, free in the Volley app.

See the Volley app